What Men Say on Day Four

On the first afternoon, they introduce themselves by job title. By the fourth day, nobody is asking what anybody does anymore.

This essay was submitted to the Modern Love column of The New York Times in November 2026.


Snow-covered Grand Teton range in winter above Jackson Hole

On the first afternoon, they introduce themselves by job title.

I have watched it happen at the Jackson Hole airport for seven winters now. A dozen men in their 40s, 50s and 60s come off the plane, bags on their shoulders, and shake hands like they are closing on a building. Within 90 seconds, someone asks, “So what do you do?” Someone else answers with his title, his company, and, if he is nervous, his head count.

I don’t blame them. I do it too. It is the only script most of us were ever handed for meeting another man.

By the fourth day, the same men are sitting in a hot spring with snow collecting in their hair, and one of them tells the others he hasn’t spoken to his brother in six years and can no longer remember why. Nobody is asking what anybody does anymore.

I have spent a long time trying to understand what happens between the arrivals gate and the hot spring. My conclusion is almost embarrassingly simple: It doesn’t take much. It just takes something we have stopped giving ourselves.

I didn’t lose my friends. That would have required an event. I just stopped seeing them.

In my 20s, friendship was ambient. It happened in kitchens, on porches, and in the back seats of cars on the way to somewhere else. I didn’t schedule it any more than I scheduled breathing. Then I started a company, got married, had two kids. Each of those things was good. Each of them also took a little of the time that friendship had quietly been living in.

There was no fight, no falling-out. I remember a friend telling me about something huge in his life weeks later and apologizing because he “didn’t want to bother me.” I remember thinking: When did I become someone it would be a bother to call?

Researchers have a name for this. They call it the friendship recession, and the numbers for men are stark: in 1990, 3 percent of American men said they had no close friends; by 2021 it was 15 percent. I didn’t need the survey. I had lived it.

So seven years ago, I did the only thing I really know how to do. I planned a trip.

I have worked in travel for more than 20 years. I know how to book rooms, hire guides, and build a day with some room in it. I invited a handful of my oldest friends to Jackson, Wyo., in January — a place I love, with long nights and mornings cold enough that people tend to stay in the same room. Snowshoe, eat, talk, ski, explore. That was the whole agenda.

It worked, which surprised me less than what happened next. The friends brought friends. The friends of friends brought theirs. A few years in, I looked around the dinner table and realized I knew maybe a quarter of the men there. The rest were strangers; to me, and to one another.

And it didn’t matter. That was the part I couldn’t stop thinking about. The men who had never met were opening up on the same schedule as the men who had known each other for 30 years. Sometimes faster.

Here is what I have learned about the four days.

On Day 1, everyone performs. The résumé comes out. There is a lot of talk about gear, about their flights, about the economy.

On Day 2, the body takes over. A day at altitude humbles a 50-year-old in a way nothing in his office can. Someone falls. Someone has to stop on the traverse to catch his breath. Men who were holding court at dinner are now quietly helping one another click back into their bindings. Competence turns out to be a lousy basis for friendship. Shared incompetence is a great one.

On Day 3, the side-by-side conversations start: on chairlifts, in the van, walking back from dinner on an icy sidewalk. Men, I’ve noticed, rarely say the real thing while looking at each other. They say it while looking at a mountain. Ten minutes on a chairlift is a confessional with a view and a built-in exit.

On Day 4, it all comes up at once; in the hot spring, by the fire, over the last dinner. A man talks about his divorce without turning it into a joke. Another says his son hasn’t returned his calls since Thanksgiving. Another admits he is retiring in the spring and is terrified, not about the money but because he doesn’t know who he will talk to once the work email stops. And the other men, strangers on Monday, don’t try to fix anything. They just stay.

I used to think men didn’t want this. That we were built for the stoic nod and the shoulder punch, and the rest was something other people were better at. I don’t believe that anymore. I have seen too many men practically run toward it once someone makes room.

What we lack isn’t desire. It’s conditions. When I take apart what happens in those four days, I keep landing on the same few ingredients. Time without an exit: No one can leave early for a meeting. A little physical difficulty, shared. Something to look at besides each other. And one person who goes first — who says the true thing out loud and survives it.

That’s it. No retreat leader, no talking stick. Nobody is assigned a feeling. You could do this in a rented cabin two hours from home. The magic isn’t the mountains, as much as I love them. It’s that for 96 hours, nobody has anywhere else to be.

Most of us have built our lives so that we always have somewhere else to be. We call it being busy, or being responsible, and it is both. It is also a very efficient way to never be known.

Eventually I turned what I had stumbled on into a small company that runs trips like this for men in the second half of life. But the truest thing I can say about it is that I built it for myself first. I needed a structure that made friendship mandatory, because I had already proved that if it was optional, I would let it go.

Next January, I turn 50. For my birthday, I have asked a group of friends to hike into the Teton backcountry with me for four days. Some I have known since college. Some I run with in Durham before work, talking about everything except the things that matter; until mile four, when sometimes we do. A year ago I would have called this a birthday trip. Now I know what it is. It’s me making room.

We don’t have good language for love between men who aren’t brothers. We say “buddy.” We say “my guy.” We say “love you, man” fast, at the end of a phone call, so it can pass for a sign-off.

But I have stood at the airport curb on enough last mornings to know what it looks like. The men who shook hands like business partners on Monday hug on Friday, and the hugs are long and a little awkward, and nobody wants to be the one who lets go first.

A month later, a photo arrives on my phone: four of them at a bar in New York City, none of whom had met before January. The caption says, “Day 5.”

Brandon Warner | Founder, The Kindred Route

Reading about it is fine. Going is better.